Make your own free website on Tripod.com

Sailing with Solar Propulsion

Some Controversy

Dr. Gold challenges solar sailing.

Home | Cosmos 1 | More on Sailing | The Physics of Solar Sailing | Physics Continued | Pictures and info | N/A | Some Controversy | Solar Sail Designs

A physicist is claiming that solar sailing -- the idea of using sunlight to blow spacecraft across the solar system -- is at odds with the laws of thermal physics.

But Thomas Gold from Cornell University in New York says the proponents of solar sailing have forgotten about thermodynamics, the branch of physics governing heat transfer.                                                                                                   

Gold writes, The radiation pressure exerted by incoherent light on diverse surfaces is examined. The thermodynamic rule, first given by Carnot in 1824, describes the limitation to the amount of free energy that can be obtained from a source of thermal energy, and he gave the compelling reason for this rule, that if more free energy than he had prescribed could ever be extracted, then a heat pump could use that free energy and re-create all the heat energy that had been consumed. A perpetual motion machine could then be constructed. Now, 179 years later, it is proposed to fly a spacecraft that is expected to gain velocity from the radiation pressure the sunlight is expected to exert on solar sails, panels of thin plastic sheets, mirror surfaced on the side facing the sun. However a detailed examination of this proposal shows it to be in direct conflict with Carnot's rule, and no such pressure can be expected. Either Carnot's accepted rule is in error, or the solar sail proposal will not work at all.

http://www.primidi.com/2003/07/03.html

 

For more about the controversy regarding solar sailing, visit the following websites: